November 18, 2026
anticipated-surge-in-religious-discrimination-claims-reshapes-employer-compliance-landscape-amidst-shifting-eeoc-priorities

WASHINGTON D.C. – A palpable sense of anticipation regarding a potential wave of religious discrimination claims against employers permeated recent discussions at the American Bar Association’s (ABA) 2026 Labor & Employment Law conference. Attorneys convening over the past weekend highlighted growing suspicions that such claims are poised to become a significant challenge for businesses, a concern amplified by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s (EEOC) visibly shifting priorities, underscored by recent high-profile nominations and hearings. This evolving landscape suggests a complex period ahead for legal practitioners and human resources professionals grappling with workplace equity, inclusion, and the delicate balance of diverse employee rights.

The Legal Landscape: Bostock and Beyond

A key session on Saturday at the ABA LEL conference, delving into the EEOC’s perceived distancing from LGBTQ+ discrimination claims, brought into sharp focus the foundational implications of the landmark Supreme Court case, Bostock v. Clayton County, Ga. (2020). Nonnie Shivers, a shareholder at Ogletree Deakins, led discussions alongside fellow attorneys Andrew Adelman, principal at Joseph, Greenwald and Laake PA, and Samantha Peters, founder and principal lawyer at Black Femme Legal. The panelists meticulously dissected how Bostock established a critical precedent under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, prohibiting employment discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity concerning hiring and firing decisions. However, they pointed out a crucial limitation: Bostock deliberately did not address issues related to gendered spaces, such as bathrooms, locker rooms, or other facilities. This omission, the attorneys posited, sets the stage for future legal battles to be fought on these very "bathroom battlegrounds," with religious accommodations increasingly central to the discourse.

The legal framework governing workplace discrimination is multifaceted, requiring employers to navigate a complex patchwork of federal, state, and local laws. While Bostock provided federal protection for LGBTQ+ individuals in employment decisions, many states and jurisdictions, including Washington D.C., had already enacted their own, often more expansive, protections. This creates a challenging environment for employers, who must reconcile varying legal standards and community expectations. The tension arises when these protections intersect with sincerely held religious beliefs, particularly concerning issues of gender identity and expression in shared spaces.

The "Bathroom Battleground" and Selina S. v. Driscoll

One notable case that offers a glimpse into the future of these disputes is Selina S. v. Driscoll. In this EEOC ruling, it was determined that Title VII permits federal agencies to restrict transgender workers from using bathrooms that align with their gender identity. While this ruling directly applies only to federal employees, Shivers emphasized its significant potential implications for private employers. "I think we will see this as we start to see religious claims as the basis to challenge bathroom usage. Really, in the next two years, I assure you that that’s where we’re going to see a predominant uptick," Shivers predicted, highlighting the urgency of understanding these evolving legal interpretations.

The challenge for employers, as articulated by Shivers, is to reconcile these seemingly contradictory mandates. On one hand, there’s a growing expectation, and in many places a legal requirement, to provide inclusive environments for LGBTQ+ employees. On the other, the EEOC’s stance in cases like Selina S. v. Driscoll, combined with its broader shift towards prioritizing religious freedom, creates a pathway for employees to assert religious objections to certain workplace accommodations or policies. Shivers shared a common scenario she encounters: "What I deal with every day is, ‘Hey, we have so-and-so saying they have a religious right not to urinate beside someone who’s transitioning.’ That’s a stretch, but we know the EEOC is going to take up the mantle on that – but not the state agencies." This stark contrast between federal and state enforcement priorities places employers in a precarious position, forcing them to balance potentially conflicting legal obligations and employee rights.

The Selina S. v. Driscoll case is particularly instructive because the court’s reasoning compared religious accommodation to pregnancy accommodation under Title VII. The judge described how Title VII grants "most favored status" to religion, mandating that workers must be granted reasonable accommodation for religious expression unless it imposes an "undue hardship" on the employer. The court, however, argued that the same level of protection and "most favored status" was not explicitly extended to transgender individuals under Title VII in the same manner. This interpretation, if widely adopted, could significantly bolster the legal standing of religious objections in workplace settings, especially when pitted against gender identity protections.

A New Direction at the Commission

Another ABA LEL session on Saturday directly addressed the operational problems and strategic shifts arising from the EEOC’s distinct approach to enforcement. Moderated by Puamuh Ghogomu, associate general counsel at W.W. Grainger, the panel featured Lisa Banks, a founding partner of Katz Banks Kumin LLP; Victoria Lipnic, a former EEOC commissioner and partner at Resolution Economics; and Camille Olson, partner at Seyfarth Shaw LLP. Their discussion underscored the growing complexity for employers in anticipating and responding to EEOC actions.

The panelists highlighted that employers might now need to scrutinize whether mandatory diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) training, or other workplace initiatives, could inadvertently be perceived as creating a hostile work environment for individuals with religious objections. Lipnic cautioned that employers and their legal counsel should closely monitor the outcome of EEOC v. Coca-Cola Beverages Northeast. This ongoing case involves allegations that a mandatory anti-racism training created a hostile work environment for certain employees, and its resolution could establish a significant precedent for how the EEOC views challenges to workplace training programs, particularly if religious objections are raised. "I think we’re going to see more of them, and I think they’re going to be cued to the issue of alleged accommodations relating to religious and other protections," Olson concurred, signaling a broader trend.

Key Nominations and Their Significance

The anticipation among legal professionals is not unfounded; it is rooted in observable shifts within the EEOC’s leadership and expressed priorities. Former President Trump recently announced his nomination of Matthew Zandi, currently chief of staff and special counsel in the U.S. Department of Justice, to an open EEOC commissioner slot. This nomination, if confirmed, would solidify a Republican majority on the Commission, potentially ensuring the longevity and robust enforcement of Chair Andrea Lucas’s agenda. Chair Lucas has been an outspoken advocate for religious freedom protections, previously stating in August 2025 (a date that likely reflects a forward-looking projection or a misstated past date in the original, but clearly indicating a policy stance) that the EEOC had "doubled down on religious rights." She asserted, "During the previous administration, workers’ religious protections too often took a backseat to woke policies. Under my leadership, the EEOC is restoring evenhanded enforcement of Title VII – ensuring that workers are not forced to choose between their paycheck and their faith."

Further cementing this trajectory, the nomination of Catherine Eschbach for EEOC general counsel moved forward with a hearing recently. During her hearing, Eschbach explicitly identified protecting the rights of religious Americans as one of her top priorities, should she secure the appointment. These appointments are crucial because the General Counsel’s office plays a pivotal role in initiating and prosecuting litigation on behalf of the EEOC, directly influencing the types of cases the agency pursues and the legal theories it advances. A General Counsel focused on religious protections could significantly alter the enforcement landscape, leading to a noticeable increase in religious discrimination lawsuits and a more sympathetic review of such claims.

Broader Implications for Employers

The implications of these developments for employers are profound and multi-layered. Businesses, particularly those operating across state lines, already contend with a complex legal tapestry. The potential for an increased focus on religious accommodation claims, especially those challenging LGBTQ+ inclusive policies or DEI initiatives, introduces a new layer of complexity.

Firstly, HR departments will need to revisit and potentially revise their policies and training materials. Standard DEI programs, designed to foster inclusivity and combat various forms of discrimination, may now come under scrutiny. Employers might face challenges from employees asserting religious objections to specific training modules, gender-neutral language policies, or accommodations for transgender colleagues. The legal standard for religious accommodation under Title VII requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations unless doing so would impose an "undue hardship." However, the definition of "undue hardship" for religious accommodation is generally considered less stringent than for disability accommodation, often requiring only a "de minimis" cost or burden. This lower bar could make it easier for employees to demand accommodations based on religious beliefs.

Secondly, the shift could significantly impact workplace culture. As companies strive to create inclusive environments, the rise of religious discrimination claims that challenge these efforts could lead to internal tensions. Balancing the rights of employees to practice their faith with the rights of other employees to a workplace free from discrimination and harassment will require careful judgment and robust internal communication strategies.

Thirdly, the potential for increased litigation is a significant concern. Companies may see a rise in charges filed with the EEOC, leading to costly investigations, mediation, and potentially, lawsuits. Legal defense costs, settlement payouts, and potential reputational damage could be substantial. Employers will need to ensure their legal counsel is well-versed in the nuances of religious accommodation law and the evolving interpretations coming from the EEOC.

Strategic Considerations for HR and Legal Teams

Given the anticipated shifts, employers must proactively prepare. This includes:

  • Policy Review: A thorough review of existing anti-discrimination, harassment, and accommodation policies to ensure they are compliant with both state and federal laws, and adaptable to the EEOC’s evolving interpretations.
  • Training Adaptation: Carefully designed training programs that balance inclusivity with respect for religious freedom, potentially offering opt-out clauses for certain modules where religious objections are genuinely held, or ensuring that training content is framed neutrally.
  • Accommodation Process Enhancement: Developing robust and consistent processes for handling accommodation requests, including those based on religion. This requires open dialogue, documentation, and a clear understanding of what constitutes "undue hardship."
  • Legal Counsel Engagement: Regular consultation with legal experts specializing in labor and employment law to stay abreast of EEOC guidance, court decisions, and legislative changes.
  • Fostering Dialogue: Encouraging open and respectful dialogue among employees about diverse beliefs and identities, aiming to build a culture of mutual understanding rather than conflict.

Conclusion

The insights from the ABA LEL conference, combined with the recent personnel changes and expressed priorities within the EEOC, paint a clear picture: religious discrimination claims are poised to become a dominant feature of employment law in the coming years. For employers, this is not merely a legalistic shift but a fundamental challenge to how they foster inclusive workplaces, manage diverse employee populations, and navigate an increasingly complex regulatory environment. The prudent path forward involves vigilance, proactive policy adjustments, and a deep understanding of the delicate balance required to uphold the rights and protections afforded to all employees under Title VII.