In a landmark decision that marks the first judicial interpretation of Washington’s landmark immigration privacy laws, Spokane County Superior Court Judge Marla L. Polin ruled on Friday, November 13, 2026, that the Adams County Sheriff’s Office systematically violated state law by collaborating with federal immigration authorities. The ruling concluded that the county’s practices of sharing inmate rosters, release dates, and facilitating custodial transfers to federal agents directly contravened the Keep Washington Working Act (KWW), a 2019 statute designed to decouple local law enforcement from federal civil immigration enforcement.
The court’s decision follows a multi-year legal battle initiated by the Washington State Attorney General’s Office, which alleged that Adams County, a predominantly rural region in the central part of the state, had intentionally ignored state mandates in favor of long-standing informal agreements with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP). The ruling grants a permanent injunction against the county, requiring an immediate overhaul of its internal policies and a cessation of unauthorized data sharing.
The Legal Conflict: State Mandates vs. Local Practice
The crux of the litigation centered on the Keep Washington Working Act, which was signed into law in May 2019. The Act prohibits state and local law enforcement agencies from using agency funds, facilities, property, or personnel to investigate, interrogate, or detain individuals for civil immigration enforcement purposes. Crucially, the law restricts the sharing of non-public personal information—such as release dates and home addresses—with federal immigration authorities unless required by a court order or for criminal justice purposes unrelated to immigration status.
During the two-day bench trial held in July 2026, the Washington Attorney General’s Office presented evidence that the Adams County Sheriff’s Office (ACSO) had maintained a "business as usual" approach despite the passage of the KWW. Judge Polin’s nearly 50-page ruling detailed how sheriff’s personnel routinely emailed updated lists of individuals in custody to ICE and CBP agents. These lists were found to be more comprehensive and timely than the public jail rosters available online, providing federal agents with a tactical advantage in identifying and locating individuals for potential deportation.
Furthermore, the court found that jail staff proactively disclosed the anticipated release times and locations of inmates to federal agents. This information allowed ICE and CBP officers to wait just outside or even inside jail facilities to take individuals into custody the moment they were technically "released" from county supervision. The court noted at least six specific instances between 2021 and 2023 where federal officials took custody of individuals in this manner based on information provided by the ACSO.
Evidence of Non-Compliance and Policy Failures
A significant portion of the ruling focused on the ACSO’s failure to update its written manuals to reflect state law. While the Washington Attorney General’s Office had issued guidance and model policies shortly after the KWW’s enactment, Adams County Sheriff Dale Wagner testified that he saw no reason to alter his department’s existing protocols. Wagner, who has served as sheriff since 2015, maintained that his office’s actions were consistent with public safety and federal cooperation.
Judge Polin expressed skepticism regarding the Sheriff’s defense that verbal instructions were sufficient to ensure compliance. While Wagner claimed he had told staff to stop sending inmate rosters after receiving a warning letter from the Attorney General in September 2023, the court found that these instructions were never codified into the binding written policies that govern deputy and corrections officer conduct.
"Defendant’s attempt to make its policies ‘a moving target’… stands in sharp contradiction to its admission that the written policies in the manual are ‘binding’ on its employees," Judge Polin wrote. The court emphasized that without clear, written directives, the risk of continued violations remained high, necessitating a court-ordered mandate for policy revision.
The ruling also highlighted a specific 2023 incident involving the arrest of two men on suspicion of possession of a stolen vehicle. The court found that an ACSO sergeant allowed a CBP agent to interview at least one of the suspects without first obtaining the suspect’s consent or providing a required cautionary statement regarding the purpose of the interview. This action was cited as a direct violation of KWW provisions that protect individuals from coercive immigration interrogations while in local custody.
Chronology of the Dispute
The legal path to Friday’s ruling was marked by several years of administrative friction and escalating litigation:
- May 2019: Governor Jay Inslee signs the Keep Washington Working Act into law, establishing Washington as a "sanctuary state" and setting strict limits on local-federal immigration cooperation.
- 2019–2023: The Adams County Sheriff’s Office continues to share inmate rosters and release data with ICE and CBP, maintaining that such cooperation is essential for law enforcement.
- September 2023: The Washington State Attorney General’s Office sends a formal warning letter to Adams County, notifying the Sheriff’s Office that its practices appear to violate state law.
- March 2025: After determining that the county had not sufficiently altered its practices, the Attorney General files a lawsuit in Spokane County Superior Court.
- July 2026: A two-day bench trial is held, featuring testimony from Sheriff Wagner, jail staff, and experts on state immigration law.
- November 13, 2026: Judge Marla L. Polin issues the final ruling and permanent injunction against Adams County.
Constitutional Challenges and Federal Preemption
In its defense, Adams County argued that the Keep Washington Working Act was unconstitutional, asserting that it was preempted by federal immigration laws. The county’s legal team, led by Joel B. Ard, argued that the state could not legally obstruct the federal government’s ability to enforce immigration statutes and that the KWW impermissibly singled out federal agencies for disparate treatment.
Judge Polin rejected these arguments, aligning with previous federal court rulings that have upheld the "anti-commandeering" principle of the Tenth Amendment. This principle establishes that the federal government cannot compel state or local officials to administer federal regulatory programs. The judge reasoned that because the KWW regulates the conduct of state and local entities—not the federal government itself—it does not violate the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
The court further clarified that the state has a legitimate interest in managing its own resources and maintaining trust between law enforcement and immigrant communities. By limiting the role of local police in immigration enforcement, the state aims to ensure that victims and witnesses of crimes feel safe reporting incidents to local authorities without fear of deportation.
Reactions from the Parties
Following the ruling, Washington State Attorney General Nick Brown hailed the decision as a landmark victory for civil rights.
"Today’s ruling is a victory for the rights and dignity of all Washingtonians, regardless of where they were born, and an affirmation that local law enforcement cannot be co-opted by the federal government," Brown said in a statement. "Today’s ruling allows our state to continue building trust and confidence between law enforcement and immigrant communities as the federal administration undermines those efforts with its draconian policies."
Conversely, Sheriff Dale Wagner expressed disappointment and signaled his intent to appeal the decision to a higher court. Wagner characterized the KWW and the court’s interpretation of it as a threat to public safety.
"Our State and its current administration continue to support sanctuary state policies that, in my opinion, place unnecessary restrictions on law enforcement and create opportunities for dangerous individuals to return to our communities rather than be held accountable," Wagner said in an email. "I firmly believe that no law should prevent local law enforcement from working with federal authorities when doing so can help keep violent criminals off our streets."
Broader Implications for Washington State
The ruling in State of Washington v. Adams County Sheriff’s Office is expected to have significant ripple effects across the Evergreen State. As the first court decision to interpret the KWW, it provides a judicial roadmap for how the law must be applied in Washington’s 39 counties.
Legal analysts suggest that other rural counties with high immigrant populations—such as Franklin, Yakima, and Grant—may now face increased scrutiny from the Attorney General’s Office and advocacy groups. The permanent injunction against Adams County serves as a warning that "verbal policies" and informal cooperation with federal agents will no longer be tolerated under Washington law.
Furthermore, the decision underscores the deep political and geographical divide within Washington regarding immigration policy. While urban centers like Seattle and Olympia have long embraced sanctuary status, rural agricultural regions often view federal immigration enforcement as a necessary component of local security.
As the case moves toward a likely appeal, the focus will shift to whether the Washington State Supreme Court will uphold Judge Polin’s interpretation. For now, the ruling stands as a definitive statement that in the state of Washington, the "Keep Washington Working Act" is not merely a set of guidelines, but a binding legal mandate that restricts local law enforcement from acting as an arm of federal immigration authorities.
